Get free quotes

How much cover

What it costs

Critical illness claims: how many are paid?

About nine in ten. ABI and GRiD figures show 90.2% of new critical illness claims were paid in 2025, across individual and group policies: 20,498 claims worth £1,422 million. On individual policies, the ABI puts the average payout at £67,000, and cancer made up 65% of claims.

A man reading a letter at the back door of his cottage

In short

  • In 2025, 90.2% of new critical illness claims were paid: 20,498 claims worth £1,422 million in total. These ABI and GRiD figures combine individual and group policies.
  • In 2025, published payout rates were 90.7% at Aviva (including children’s benefit and TPD) and 92.9% at Legal & General. Vitality paid 87.3% (Serious Illness Cover) and Zurich paid 93.8%.
  • Cancer made up 65% of individual critical illness claims in 2025, more than any other cause. The ABI puts the average individual payout that year at £67,000.
  • Aviva, Legal & General and Vitality all say the claims they decline most often fail the policy’s definition or severity threshold. Across individual protection claims in 2024, the ABI also named not disclosing an existing medical condition as a common reason.
  • If you took reasonable care to answer every question honestly and to the best of your knowledge, the insurer can’t reject your claim for misrepresentation. That applies even if an answer turns out to be wrong.
  • Aviva says it usually pays a successful critical illness claim within five working days. Zurich says timescales can vary, especially when it needs information from your GP.

How many critical illness claims are paid?

In 2025, 90.2% of new critical illness claims were paid across individual and group policies. The figures, from the Association of British Insurers (ABI) and Group Risk Development (GRiD), cover 20,498 paid claims worth £1,422 million.

Critical illness cover pays a tax-free lump sum if you’re diagnosed with a condition listed in your policy. Life insurance pays out when you pass away, not when you lose income through illness. A combined life and critical illness policy pays out on whichever comes first: death or the diagnosis of a covered illness.

Across individual and group policies combined, the ABI and GRiD recorded a similar rate in 2023, at 90.5% of new claims (19,876 claims worth £1,359 million). On ABI figures for individual policies alone, payouts have passed £1 billion a year for five years in a row.

Individual critical illness claims paid in the UK, 2023 to 2025
Year Total paid Average claim
2023 £1.2 billion (a record at the time) £67,267
2024 £1.3 billion £67,600
2025 £1.25 billion £67,000

Source: Association of British Insurers (ABI), individual policies only.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) found that claims acceptance rates for pure protection are high, and that generally over 50% of premiums are paid out in claims. Counting individual life, income protection and critical illness policies together, the ABI says insurers paid 97.9% of protection claims in 2025.

In 2025, critical illness claims were paid less often than life insurance claims, both in the ABI and GRiD figures and at each insurer below. The ABI and GRiD count whole of life policies in a separate row, so their 96.7% life figure leaves them out.

Share of life and critical illness claims paid in 2025
Figure Life insurance Critical illness
Industry (ABI and GRiD, individual and group policies) 96.7% 90.2%
Aviva 98.7% (life, including over 50s plans and terminal illness) 90.7% (including children’s benefit and total permanent disability)
Legal & General 97.5% (life and over 50s) 92.9%
Vitality 99.4% (Life Cover) 87.3% (Serious Illness Cover)
Zurich 99.8% 93.8%

2025 figures as the ABI, GRiD and each insurer published them. They don’t all count the same claims, so they aren’t directly comparable.

Share of claims paid in 2025: life insurance and critical illness Each figure as the ABI, GRiD or the insurer published it, in the same order as the table above.
  • Industry (ABI and GRiD) 96.7% 90.2%
  • Aviva 98.7% 90.7%
  • Legal & General 97.5% 92.9%
  • Vitality 99.4% 87.3%
  • Zurich 99.8% 93.8%
Share of claims paid in 2025: life insurance and critical illness
Life insurance Critical illness
Industry (ABI and GRiD) 96.7% 90.2%
Aviva 98.7% 90.7%
Legal & General 97.5% 92.9%
Vitality 99.4% 87.3%
Zurich 99.8% 93.8%

They don’t all count the same claims, so they aren’t directly comparable. The table above says what each figure covers.

Who claims

In Legal & General’s 2025 figures, the average critical illness claimant was 49. Their policy had been running for 9 years on average.

Critical illness payout rates by insurer

At the four insurers in this guide, published 2025 payout rates ranged from 87.3% at Vitality to 93.8% at Zurich. Aviva paid 90.7% and Legal & General 92.9%, but they don’t all count the same claims.

Critical illness claims paid in 2025, as each insurer reports them
Insurer Claims paid Number and value What the figure covers
Aviva 90.7% 5,586 claims, more than £388 million Critical illness, children’s benefit and total permanent disability claims, for Aviva and Aviva Protection UK policies combined
Legal & General 92.9% 4,051 claims, £291 million Critical illness claims. Children’s critical illness claims are reported separately: 95.3%, 245 claims
Vitality 87.3% £42 million Serious Illness Cover, which Vitality says works differently to critical illness cover. It pays out for some conditions a typical enhanced critical illness plan doesn’t include
Zurich 93.8% 1,426 claims, £125.4 million Critical illness claims

2025 figures, as each insurer published them. They don’t all count the same claims, so they aren’t directly comparable.

Check what each insurer counts before comparing the percentages. Legal & General’s 2025 figures, for example, cover claims finalised between 1 January and 31 December 2025, with any fraudulent claims removed.

Vitality’s figures cover Serious Illness Cover, which Vitality says works differently to critical illness cover. Depending on the condition, a payout may be more than, the same as or less than a critical illness policy would pay. Vitality says 1 in 7 of the claims it paid in 2025 covered conditions a typical enhanced critical illness plan doesn’t include.

In its report on 2023 claims, Vitality estimated the payout percentage would have been around 75% if another insurer had assessed the claims made to it.

Share of critical illness claims paid each year, 2020 to 2025
Year Aviva Legal & General Vitality Zurich
2020 92.7% – – 87%
2021 92.4% – 91% –
2022 93.5% 93.4% 92.5% 91%
2023 91.6% 93% 87.8% –
2024 91.5% 93% – 90%
2025 90.7% 92.9% 87.3% 93.8%

Each insurer’s own published figure. Aviva’s include children’s benefit and total permanent disability claims; Vitality’s are for Serious Illness Cover. A dash means we don’t have a published figure for that year.

Critical illness claims paid by Aviva and Legal & General, 2022 to 2025 Share of critical illness claims paid each year, from the table above.
90%
91%
92%
93%
94%
92.9% 90.7%
2022 2023 2024 2025
Critical illness claims paid by Aviva and Legal & General, 2022 to 2025
Aviva Legal & General
2022 93.5% 93.4%
2023 91.6% 93.0%
2024 91.5% 93.0%
2025 90.7% 92.9%

Aviva’s figures include children’s benefit and total permanent disability claims. Legal & General published its 2023 and 2024 figures as whole numbers, so 93.0% means 93%. The vertical axis starts at 90%.

From 2020 to 2025, Aviva paid between 90.7% and 93.5% of these claims each year (including children’s benefit and TPD). Legal & General paid between 92.9% and 93.4% from 2022 to 2025. Zurich’s published rate ranged from 87% in 2020 to 93.8% in 2025.

A few percentage points between insurers won’t tell you how your own claim would go. There’s more on what decides a claim under why claims are declined.

Compare quotes from a panel of UK insurers

  • Quick 3 step process
  • 60 second form
  • Free quotes, no obligation

Get free quotes

Step 1 of 2

A broker will call you, usually within 1 hour.

Who needs cover?

£150,000
25 years

Have you smoked in the last 12 months?

Our broker partner Reassured is rated Excellent on Trustpilot (opens in a new tab): 4.8 out of 5 from 105,367 reviews (checked 2 October 2026).

Over 1 million families helped**

What are the most common critical illness claims?

Cancer is the most common cause. On ABI figures, it made up 65% of individual critical illness claims in 2025, up from 62% in 2024. Individual cancer payouts totalled £777 million in 2023 and £812 million in 2024.

On ABI statistics, cancer, heart attack and stroke together made up over 80% of all critical illness claims in 2016. Every critical illness policy must cover these three core conditions to at least the ABI’s standard model wordings (its minimum definitions).

Most common causes of critical illness claims in 2025, by insurer
Insurer Most common Second Third
Aviva Cancer, 54.8% Heart attack, 8.7% Stroke, 6.7%
Legal & General Cancer, 64.5% Heart-related conditions, 12.3% Neurological conditions, 9.2%
Zurich Cancer, 64% Cardiovascular, 14% Cerebrovascular (which includes stroke), 8%

Each insurer groups conditions in its own way, so the categories don’t match exactly. Aviva’s figures include children’s benefit and total permanent disability claims.

Our guide to critical illness cover conditions explains what the core definitions cover and what they leave out. The heart attack guide looks at heart claims in more detail.

How much does critical illness cover pay out?

On ABI figures, the average individual critical illness payout was £67,000 in 2025. That’s close to 2023 (£67,267) and 2024 (£67,600). Counting group policies too, the ABI and GRiD average for 2025 was £69,375.

Average critical illness payout in 2025
Figure Average payout What it covers
Industry (ABI) £67,000 Individual critical illness policies
Industry (ABI and GRiD) £69,375 Individual and group critical illness policies
Aviva £69,559 5,586 claims, including children’s benefit and total permanent disability
Legal & General £71,755 Critical illness claims
Vitality £40,516 Serious Illness Cover claims
Zurich No average stated 1,426 claims worth £125.4 million in total

2025 figures as published by the ABI, GRiD and each insurer.

Vitality’s £40,516 average isn’t directly comparable with the others. Its standard level Serious Illness Cover pays between 25% and 100% of the cover amount on each claim. In 2025, 1 in 10 of its Serious Illness Cover claims were paid on plans that had already claimed before.

The largest critical illness claims paid in 2025 were £1.4 million at Aviva and £1.2 million at Legal & General (plus £40,000 for children’s cover). Vitality’s largest Serious Illness Cover claim in 2025 was £500,000.

What you’d receive depends on your own policy, not the industry average. On Aviva’s Critical Illness Plan, a successful claim pays the cover amount as a cash lump sum. Some policies also make a smaller payment for less severe conditions or if your child has a covered illness.

To work out a figure for your household, see how much critical illness cover you might need or try the critical illness calculator. For life cover, see the average life insurance payout.

Why are critical illness claims declined?

Common reasons are not meeting the policy definitions and not disclosing an existing medical condition when taking out cover. The ABI named both for declined individual protection claims in 2024.

Critical illness claims paid and not paid in 2025, by reason
Insurer Paid Definition not met Misrepresentation or non-disclosure Other reasons
Aviva 90.7% 5.2% 3.9% 0.2%
Vitality 87.3% 10.9% 0.4% 1.4% (condition not covered)

Aviva’s figures include children’s benefit claims. Vitality’s are for Serious Illness Cover.

Aviva and Legal & General both say most of the claims they don’t pay fail to meet the policy or severity definition. Aviva’s 2025 statement covers critical illness, children’s benefit and TPD claims. Vitality says its declined Serious Illness Cover claims most often hadn’t met the severity threshold (how serious an illness must be).

When the definition isn’t met

Two Financial Ombudsman Service case studies show how this works. In one, an insurer declined a heart attack claim that didn’t meet the policy’s severity definition. The Ombudsman didn’t uphold the complaint, as the evidence didn’t show it met the policy’s definition of a severe heart attack.

In the other, the claimant’s condition was similar to one listed in her policy, but the policy only paid if a listed condition was diagnosed. Without the required diagnosis, the Ombudsman didn’t think it fair to ask the insurer to pay.

The ABI’s model definitions also exclude some early or related conditions. Its cancer wording leaves out pre-malignant cancers, cancer in situ (cancer that hasn’t spread), borderline malignancy and low malignant potential.

Its heart attack wording excludes angina or myocardial injury without myocardial infarction (a heart attack). Its stroke wording excludes transient ischaemic attack (TIA), traumatic brain injury and eye stroke.

When the application was wrong

Under the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, you must take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation (give the insurer wrong information). If you took reasonable care, the insurer can’t take any action against you, even if something was wrong.

Otherwise, the insurer can act only if it shows it wouldn’t have offered the contract at all, or would have offered different terms, without the misrepresentation. What it can do then depends on the kind of misrepresentation:

  • If it was deliberate or reckless, the insurer may cancel the policy from the start and refuse all claims. It needn’t return your premiums unless keeping them would be unfair. It’s up to the insurer to show the misrepresentation was deliberate or reckless.
  • If it was careless and the insurer wouldn’t have offered cover on any terms, it may cancel the policy and refuse all claims, but must return your premiums.
  • If it was careless and the insurer would have offered cover on different terms (other than the premium), the contract can be treated as if it had those terms.
  • If it was careless and the insurer would have charged a higher premium, it may reduce the claim payout in proportion. In the Ombudsman’s example, someone who paid £100 instead of £150 has paid two-thirds of the premium, so two-thirds of the claim should be paid.

In 2019, Zurich declined 10% of critical illness claims. Most of those declines (63%) were for conditions not covered by the policy, and 36% were for misrepresentation on application forms. All 189 critical illness claims by smokers that year were paid, as they had disclosed their smoking when applying.

Complaints to the Ombudsman

In 2025/26, the Financial Ombudsman Service received 647 new complaints about critical illness cover. Its uphold rate (the share decided in the customer’s favour) was 12%. That compares with 17% for term assurance (884 new complaints) and 30% across all financial products. An uphold rate is a share of the complaints the Ombudsman resolved, not a share of declined claims.

Not all of these complaints are about declined claims. Some are about an insurer saying an illness isn’t covered, or refusing a claim because information wasn’t disclosed. Others are about how the policy was sold, slow payment or other customer-service issues.

When looking at a complaint, the Ombudsman checks that the insurer followed the ABI guidelines and was clear about what the policy does and doesn’t cover. If it decides your illness meets the policy’s critical illness or total permanent disability definition, it can tell the insurer to pay the claim with interest.

If your claim is declined

The Ombudsman says to talk to your insurer first. It has to give you its final response within eight weeks for most types of complaint. If you’re unhappy with it, or don’t hear back in that time, you can take the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service. See life insurance claims and reasons life insurance won’t pay out for more.

How do you make a critical illness claim?

You tell your insurer by phone, online or by email, with your policy number, diagnosis and doctor’s details. The insurer may then ask your GP or consultant for medical evidence.

  1. Check your policy Aviva’s policy conditions, for example, list the full definition of each illness and when you can claim. Aviva also says most critical illness policies have a survival period (how long you must live after diagnosis before it pays), usually 10 to 14 days.
  2. Gather your details Aviva, Legal & General and Zurich ask for your policy number, details of your diagnosis and your GP’s or consultant’s contact details. For a child’s claim, Legal & General also asks for a birth certificate or legal guardianship evidence, if relevant.
  3. Tell the insurer Aviva, Legal & General and Zurich let you start a claim online or by phone. Vitality gives a phone number and an email address. Check for time limits: Vitality won’t pay a Serious Illness Cover claim unless it gets written notice within six months of the event that causes it.
  4. The insurer gathers medical evidence The insurer may ask your GP or specialist for medical evidence, and Legal & General sends forms to sign by email or post. Aviva pays for any information it asks third parties for. Zurich says independent medical examinations are occasionally needed, but they’re the exception rather than the rule.
  5. Keep paying your premiums Legal & General and Zurich both ask you to keep paying your premiums while the claim is assessed.
  6. The decision If your claim is accepted, Aviva pays the cover amount as a cash lump sum. Legal & General pays a lump sum in British pounds to a UK bank account. Aviva says it may not pay if the information you give is untrue or incomplete, and if it can’t pay, it explains why.
How to contact each insurer about a critical illness claim
Insurer Online or email Phone
Aviva Online claim form 0800 015 1142 (UK); +44 1603 603 277 from abroad, Monday to Friday 8am to 6pm
Legal & General My Account, 24/7 0800 068 0789, Monday to Friday 9am to 5pm
Vitality lifeclaims@vitality.co.uk 0345 272 8802
Zurich Online claims form; zurichmulticlaims@uk.zurich.com (PR policies) or technicalclaims@uk.zurich.com (other policies) Policy numbers starting PR: 0370 240 0073 (9am to 5pm). Other policies: 0370 243 0827 (8:30am to 5:30pm). Both Monday to Friday, excluding bank holidays

Contact details as each insurer publishes them. Your policy documents give the right contact for your policy.

Aviva’s phone numbers above are for policies bought directly from Aviva. If you bought yours through another provider, Aviva’s claims page lists a separate number under that provider’s name. Our life insurance claims guide covers the wider process, including claims after someone passes away.

How long does a critical illness claim take?

There’s no single timescale. Vitality says it depends on how complex the claim is. Zurich says timescales can vary, especially when it needs information from your GP or another medical professional.

  • Aviva says the survival period on most critical illness policies is usually 10 to 14 days after diagnosis, depending on the product. On Aviva’s Critical Illness Plan it’s 10 days after diagnosis. On Vitality’s Serious Illness Cover it’s at least 14 days after the event that causes the claim.
  • Once a critical illness claim is accepted, Aviva says it usually pays out within five working days.
  • Some definitions require a condition to be permanent: one ABI model wording for total permanent disability pays if you can never do your own occupation again.
  • For permanent conditions, the ABI Guide allows an assessment period that isn’t normally longer than 12 months, provided all the evidence is available. It typically starts when the insurer receives the claim.

Giving full details at the start can cut the back-and-forth. Legal & General’s release on 2024 claims said online submissions cut follow-up requests for extra documents on critical illness claims by more than 25%. It put that down to getting more complete information at the outset.

If your claim is delayed

Delays are one of the complaints the Financial Ombudsman Service sees about critical illness cover. If it finds your claim was unnecessarily delayed, it may tell the insurer to pay compensation for the distress and inconvenience you’ve suffered. For claims after someone passes away, see how long life insurance takes to pay out.

What to check before you buy or claim

Before you apply or claim, check the policy’s condition definitions, your application answers and any claim time limits.

  • Check how many conditions are covered. All policies must cover cancer, heart attack and stroke to at least the ABI’s standard wordings. The most comprehensive cover 50 or more conditions, but others are much more limited.
  • Answer every health and lifestyle question with care. Insurers check your medical history when you claim. If you took reasonable care to answer honestly and to the best of your knowledge, the insurer can’t reject your claim.
  • Read the terms during the cooling-off period. You have 30 days from buying a critical illness policy to change your mind and get a full refund.
  • Note any claim deadline and survival period. Vitality needs written notice within six months of a Serious Illness Cover event, and you must survive at least 14 days. Legal & General and Zurich ask you to keep paying premiums while a claim is assessed.

Compare November 2026 life insurance quotes

Fill in one quick form and a broker will call you to compare plans from a panel of UK insurers. Free quotes, no obligation.

Our broker partner Reassured is rated Excellent on Trustpilot (opens in a new tab): 4.8 out of 5 from 105,367 reviews (checked 2 October 2026).

Over 1 million families helped**

Get free quotes

Critical illness payout FAQs

90.2% of new critical illness claims were paid in 2025, on ABI and GRiD figures for individual and group policies combined. Insurers’ own 2025 figures were 90.7% at Aviva (including children’s benefit and TPD), 92.9% at Legal & General, 87.3% at Vitality (Serious Illness Cover) and 93.8% at Zurich.

Cancer. It made up 65% of individual critical illness claims in 2025, according to the ABI, up from 62% in 2024.

£67,000 on individual policies in 2025, according to the ABI. Counting group policies too, ABI and GRiD figures give £69,375. Your own payout depends on your cover. Aviva’s Critical Illness Plan pays the cover amount as a cash lump sum, and some policies pay a smaller sum for less severe conditions.

For individual protection claims in 2024, the ABI named not meeting policy definitions and not disclosing an existing medical condition at application as common reasons. For critical illness, Aviva and Legal & General both say most of the claims they don’t pay fail to meet the policy or severity definition. Aviva’s figure includes children’s benefit and TPD claims.

It varies. Vitality says it depends on how complex the claim is, and Zurich says timescales can vary, especially when it needs information from your GP. Once a claim is accepted, Aviva says it usually pays within five working days. Where a condition must be permanent, the ABI Guide says the assessment period is not normally longer than 12 months if all the evidence is available.

At Legal & General and Zurich, yes: both ask you to keep paying your regular premiums while your critical illness claim is assessed.

HMRC’s manual says a critical illness lump sum is not taxable as income for the recipient, and the ABI describes critical illness cover as a tax-free lump sum.

MoneyHelper says a critical illness policy only pays out once, after which the policy ends. Some smaller payments don’t end the main policy: at Aviva, your policy continues after a children’s benefit claim or an additional critical illness claim. Vitality says there’s no limit to the number of Serious Illness Cover claims you can make during the term. In total you can claim up to 100%, 200% or 300% of the initial cover amount, with Serious Illness Cover 1X, 2X or 3X.

Yes. The Financial Ombudsman Service says to talk to your insurer first. The insurer has to give its final response within eight weeks for most types of complaint. If you’re unhappy with the response or don’t get one within eight weeks, you can take your complaint to the Ombudsman. If it decides your illness falls within the policy definition, it can tell the insurer to pay the claim with interest.

If you took reasonable care when answering the insurer’s questions, the insurer can’t take any action against you, even if there was a misrepresentation. If you were careless, it depends on what the insurer would have done with the right information. If it would have charged a higher premium, for example, it may cut the claim in proportion.

This article is for general information only and should not be considered financial advice. The right cover depends on your personal circumstances.

Sources

The facts on this page come from these sources.

  1. Association of British Insurers: Breakdown of combined individual and group claims using data from the ABI and GRiD, 2025 (opens in a new tab); Protection insurers pay out £7.84 billion to help customers safeguard their finances (2025 claims) (opens in a new tab); Record £8bn paid out in vital protection claims during 2024 (opens in a new tab); ABI Guide to Minimum Standards for Critical Illness Cover (16 September 2022, updated April 2023) (opens in a new tab); Critical illness cover (opens in a new tab); Breakdown of combined individual and group claims using data from the ABI and GRiD, 2023 (table image "News_Table") (opens in a new tab); Protection insurers pay out record £7.34 billion to support individuals and families (2023 claims) (opens in a new tab) · keystone-cms-production-amfyhhecavg8gneq.northeurope-01.azurewebsites.net, abi.org.uk, accessed 26 September 2026 and 2 October 2026; 26 September 2026.
  2. Financial Ombudsman Service: Misrepresentation and non-disclosure (how we handle complaints: insurance, guidance for businesses) (opens in a new tab); Jorge’s insurer declines his critical illness claim (case study) (opens in a new tab); Lori’s insurer says she’s not covered for her serious illness (case study) (opens in a new tab); Annual complaints data and insight 2025/26 (opens in a new tab); Critical illness cover (opens in a new tab); Misrepresentation and non-disclosure (information for consumers) (opens in a new tab) · financial-ombudsman.org.uk, accessed 26 September 2026; 2 October 2026; 26 September 2026 and 2 October 2026.
  3. MoneyHelper: Why providers might reject your insurance claim – and what to do if this happens (opens in a new tab); What is life insurance? (opens in a new tab); What is critical illness cover? (opens in a new tab) · moneyhelper.org.uk, accessed 26 September 2026.
  4. Financial Conduct Authority: MS24/1.3: Structure of the UK pure protection market for retail customers (September 2025) (opens in a new tab); MS24/1.5: Pure Protection Market Study – Market Study Final Report (September 2026) (opens in a new tab) · fca.org.uk, accessed 26 September 2026.
  5. legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, section 2: disclosure and representations before contract or variation (latest revised version) (opens in a new tab); Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, section 4: qualifying misrepresentations: definition and remedies (opens in a new tab); Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, Schedule 1: insurers' remedies for qualifying misrepresentations (opens in a new tab); Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, section 5: qualifying misrepresentations: classification and presumptions (opens in a new tab) · legislation.gov.uk, accessed 26 September 2026.
  6. Aviva: Children’s critical illness benefit (opens in a new tab) · aviva.co.uk, accessed 26 September 2026.
  7. GOV.UK: IPTM6010 - Sickness, disability, unemployment and long-term care insurance: introduction and overview (opens in a new tab) · gov.uk, accessed 26 September 2026.
  8. Insurer documents: Aviva, Legal & General, Vitality, Zurich.
    Show the 35 documents